Engineering Structures Jobs in Spring Valley Lake, CA

Premises Liability Associate

Location – (California)

Costa Mesa

Remote Work Flexibility

Experience the freedom of working remotely for a portion of your workweek. Our infrastructure enables seamless communication, collaboration, and access to resources from anywhere.

About the Company

Manning Kass is a national civil litigation defense firm that stands out from the rest—every case and client matters. Established in 1994 with just sixteen attorneys, we have expanded over the past thirty years to more than 160 attorneys across seven offices, including major economic hubs like New York and Los Angeles.

About the Role

Manning Kass has an exciting opportunity for an Associate, with at least 2+ years of civil litigation experience, to join our Team in one of our California offices!

This specialized Team defends clients in high-stakes litigation; representing commercial corporations, while advising clients regarding risk mitigation. The ideal candidate will have excellent communication skills and the ability to interact with clients, businesses and legal teams. Associates work closely with lead attorneys daily, engaging in all phases of litigation—from case evaluation to discovery through trial —focusing on strategic thinking to achieve client goals. We seek candidates who are eager to learn, highly self-motivated, and interested in long-term professional growth.

Responsibilities

• Attending court hearings, participating in site inspections, taking and defending depositions.
• Drafting extensive written discovery, including preparing and responding to interrogatories, documents requests and requests for admissions.
• Evaluating, analyzing, assessing, and executing litigation strategies.
• Proactively manage communications with clients throughout the course of litigation.

Professional Development Opportunities

We are committed to investing in our team's professional growth. Our distinctive "Manning Kass University" training program offers tailored education and development opportunities to help you thrive as a successful lawyer. Opportunity to mediate, arbitrate, and try cases while learning from the firm's experienced ABOTA trial attorneys.

Requirements

• Juris Doctor (J.D.) degree.
• 2+ years of civil litigation experience.
• Active membership in the California State Bar and in good standing.
• Demonstrated experience in premises liability litigation, preferably within a law firm setting.
• Strong legal research and writing skills, with attention to detail.
• Excellent time management skills and ability to manage and meet deadlines

Company Offers

• Salary starting at $125,000 - $180,000. Salary is commensurate with experience.
• We offer a lucrative and generous bonus structure.
• Comprehensive benefits package, including medical, dental, vision, disability, life, flexible spending account, and 401K.
• Pet insurance coverage.
• Referral program.
• A company culture that fosters career growth and opportunity.
• All applications will be treated with the utmost confidentiality.

We are partnering with two well-established law firms in San Diego that are seeking Employment Law Attorneys to join their growing practices. These firms represent employers in a broad range of California employment matters, including wage & hour disputes, wrongful termination, harassment and discrimination claims, PAGA actions, and other complex workplace litigation. The teams offer strong compensation, a collaborative environment, and no rigid billable requirements.

Key Responsibilities:

• Manage employment law matters from pre-litigation through resolution, including trial or arbitration when necessary.
• Conduct depositions, discovery, motion practice, and court appearances.
• Draft pleadings, motions, and briefs with strong legal analysis and advocacy.
• Advise clients on California employment compliance and risk mitigation.
• Represent clients in mediations, arbitrations, and administrative proceedings.

Ideal Background:

• 2+ years of experience practicing Employment Law in California.
• Active membership in good standing with the California Bar.
• Strong research, writing, and litigation skills.
• Ability to manage matters independently while working in a team-oriented environment.
• Experience with PAGA, wage & hour, or complex employment disputes is a plus.

Salary and Other Compensation:

The annual base salary range for this position is $150,000 – $300,000, plus eligibility for discretionary annual bonuses. Actual compensation within this range will be determined based on factors such as location/market, skills, education, experience, and other relevant qualifications.

Benefits:

• Medical insurance (80% paid by employer)
• Dental insurance (80% paid by employer)
• Vision insurance (80% paid by employer)
• 401(k) 3% match
• 3 weeks of PTO
• Billable + Annual Discretionary bonus structure

Paralegal (Litigation) – Contract-to-Hire

Location: San Diego, CA (Hybrid)

Compensation: $80,000 – $100,000

We are partnering with a well-established litigation law firm in San Diego that is seeking an experienced Paralegal to support a team of attorneys and paralegals in a fast-paced, detail-oriented environment. This is a contract-to-hire opportunity offering the chance to join a highly collaborative team that values strong organization, accuracy, and high-quality legal work.

This role will support litigation matters from discovery through trial preparation and will require someone who is comfortable managing multiple responsibilities and working in a structured legal environment with strict deadlines.

Responsibilities:

• Prepare indexes and chronologies of produced documents
• Maintain and update privilege logs
• Assist with discovery including interrogatories, document requests, subpoenas, and document productions
• Organize exhibits for pleadings and court submissions
• Prepare materials for depositions and summarize deposition transcripts
• Coordinate and electronically file pleadings with the court
• Conduct legal and public records research using tools such as Westlaw
• Assist with drafting letters, responses to complaints, and settlement agreements
• Prepare mediation submissions and support trial preparation
• Organize and track documents received from clients and the court
• Assist with e-discovery searches and document uploads
• Proofread and format legal documents including tables of contents and authorities

Qualifications:

• 5+ years of Paralegal experience, preferably within a litigation environment
• Strong understanding of law firm procedures and court filing requirements
• Experience supporting discovery, document production, and trial preparation
• Excellent grammar, proofreading, and document formatting skills
• Strong research abilities, including experience with Westlaw and online legal research tools
• Proficiency in Microsoft Office (Word, Outlook, Excel, PowerPoint)
• Highly organized with strong attention to detail and ability to manage multiple priorities

Schedule:

Full-time, Monday–Friday (8:30 AM – 5:00 PM) with limited overtime as needed.

Work Arrangement:

Hybrid schedule with a minimum of two days per week in the San Diego office (three days during onboarding and training).

If you are an experienced litigation paralegal looking for a contract-to-hire opportunity with a reputable law firm, we would welcome the opportunity to connect and discuss the role further.

General Liability Associate

Locations (California)

Costa Mesa

Hybrid Work Flexibility

This role requires a minimum of two in-office days per week, with the flexibility to work remotely for the remainder of the week. Our robust infrastructure ensures seamless communication, collaboration, and access to resources from anywhere.

About the Company

Manning Kass is a national civil litigation defense firm that stands out from the rest—every case and client matters. Established in 1994 with just sixteen attorneys, we have expanded over the past thirty years to more than 160 attorneys across seven offices, including major economic hubs like New York and Los Angeles.

About the Role

Our General Liability team represents restaurants, retail stores, and other businesses in a wide range of matters, premises liability, products liability and business litigation. Our practice also encompasses the defense of personal and catastrophic injury claims, and foodborne illness disputes. We are seeking a highly motivated and well-rounded General Liability Associate with at least one (1) year of experience in to join our team.

As an associate, you will work closely with experienced litigators and industry-leading partners, gaining hands-on experience in every stage of litigation—from case evaluation and discovery to mediation, arbitration, and trial. We are looking for a driven, intellectually curious attorney eager to make a meaningful impact for our clients while advancing their career in a collaborative and forward-thinking environment. The ideal candidate is highly-motivated, eager to learn, and committed to long-term professional growth.

Responsibilities

• Manage all aspects of written discovery, including drafting and responding to discovery requests, preparing meet and confer letters, and handling discovery-related motions.
• Take and defend depositions, attend site inspections, and interview witnesses.
• Appear at court hearings, mediations, and arbitrations.
• Develop and execute litigation strategies, including case evaluation and risk assessment.
• Maintain proactive communication with clients throughout litigation.

Professional Development Opportunities

We are committed to investing in our associates professional growth. Our distinctive "Manning Kass University" training program offers tailored education and development opportunities to help you thrive as a successful lawyer. Opportunity to mediate, arbitrate, and try cases while learning from the firm's experienced ABOTA trial attorneys.

Requirements

• Juris Doctor (J.D.) degree.
• Active member of the California State Bar in good standing.
• One (1) year of civil litigation experience.
• Proven experience in premises liability litigation, ideally in a law firm environment.
• Strong legal research and writing abilities with keen attention to detail.

Company Offers

• Salary starting at $125,000 - $180,000. Salary is commensurate with experience.
• We offer a lucrative and generous bonus structure.
• Comprehensive benefits package, including medical, dental, vision, disability, life, flexible spending account, and 401K.
• Pet insurance coverage.
• Referral program.
• A company culture that fosters career growth and opportunity.
• All applications will be treated with the utmost confidentiality.

Senior Transportation Litigation Associate

Office Locations

San Diego

Remote Work Flexibility

Experience the freedom of working remotely for a portion of your workweek. Our infrastructure enables seamless communication, collaboration, and access to resources from anywhere.

About the Company

Manning Kass is a national civil litigation defense firm that stands out from the rest—every case and client matters. Established in 1994 with just sixteen attorneys, we have expanded over the past thirty years to more than 160 attorneys across seven offices, including major economic hubs like New York and Los Angeles.

About the Role

Manning Kass is seeking a senior litigation associate to join our San Diego office in a hybrid remote capacity. The ideal candidate will work on a diverse range of Transportation, Automobile and Trucking cases. The candidate will work closely with senior associates and partners daily, engaging in all phases of litigation—from case evaluation and discovery to trial presentation—focusing on strategic thinking to achieve client goals. We seek candidates who are eager to learn, highly self-motivated, and interested in long-term professional growth.

Responsibilities

• Independently manage cases, overseeing matters through all stages of the litigation process from inception through trial.
• Attending Court hearing, managing discovery, as well as taking and defending depositions.
• Proactively managing communications with clients throughout the course of litigation.
• Timely and accurate reporting to our clients and ensuring compliance with the case management requirements.

Professional Development Opportunities

We are committed to investing in our team's professional growth. Our distinctive "Manning Kass University" training program offers tailored education and development opportunities to help you thrive as a successful lawyer. Opportunity to mediate, arbitrate, and try cases while learning from the firm's experienced ABOTA trial attorneys.

Requirements

• Juris Doctor (J.D.) degree is required.
• You must be licensed to practice in the State of California.
• The ideal candidate should have 3+ years of transportation litigation experience.
• Exceptional communication and advocacy skills, both verbal and written.
• Time management skills and ability to manage and meet deadlines is required.
• Experience handling discovery for complex matters, with substantial knowledge of evidentiary objections in responding to discovery.
• Strong critical thinking, interpersonal skills and the ability to exercise common sense in complex situations while reporting to clients and carriers.

Company Offers

• Salary starting at $130,000 - $185,000. Salary is commensurate with experience.
• We offer a lucrative and generous bonus structure.
• Comprehensive benefits package, including medical, dental, vision, disability, life, flexible spending account, and 401K.
• Pet insurance coverage.
• Referral program.
• A company culture that fosters career growth and opportunity.
• All applications will be treated with the utmost confidentiality.

Junior Litigation Attorney

Office Location

San Diego

Remote Work Flexibility

Experience the freedom of working remotely for a portion of your workweek. Our infrastructure enables seamless communication, collaboration, and access to resources from anywhere.

About the Company

Manning Kass is a national civil litigation defense firm that stands out from the rest—every case and client matters. Established in 1994 with just sixteen attorneys, we have expanded over the past thirty years to more than 160 attorneys across seven offices, including major economic hubs like New York and Los Angeles.

About the Role

Manning | Kass is seeking a Junior Litigation Attorney to join our San Diego office. This role offers the chance to thrive in a diverse, inclusive, and flexible work environment while benefiting from industry recognition and top-tier mentorship.

Responsibilities

• Analyze, assess, and execute litigation strategies through all stages of litigation.
• Conduct depositions, take examinations under oath (EUO), propound and respond to written discovery.
• Maintain proactive communication with clients, offering detailed liability and damage analyses.
• Represent clients in litigation proceedings, such as hearings, motions, depositions, and mediations.
• Review pleadings, motions, and other legal documents.
• Develop legal strategies to resolve cases favorably and cost-effectively for clients.

Professional Development Opportunities

We are committed to investing in our team's professional growth. Our distinctive "Manning Kass University" training program offers tailored education and development opportunities to help you thrive as a successful lawyer. Opportunity to mediate, arbitrate, and try cases while learning from the firm's experienced ABOTA trial attorneys.

Requirements

• Juris Doctor (J.D.) degree is required.
• You must be licensed to practice in the State of California.
• Experience formulating and developing case strategy, advising clients on risk mitigation and case resolution options.
• Strong critical thinking, interpersonal skills and the ability to exercise common sense in complex situations while reporting to clients and carriers.

Company Offers

• Salary starting at $120,000 - $180,000. Salary is commensurate with experience.
• We offer a lucrative and generous bonus structure.
• Comprehensive benefits package, including medical, dental, vision, disability, life, flexible spending account, and 401K.
• Pet insurance coverage.
• Referral program.
• A company culture that fosters career growth and opportunity.
• All applications will be treated with the utmost confidentiality.

Employment Litigation Attorney (2+ Years) | Grow Your Practice, Not Just Your Hours

We're looking for a litigation attorney with at least 2 years of employment law experience who is eager to grow—professionally, intellectually, and eventually in their own client base.

This role is built for an attorney who wants more than back-office research or being shielded from clients. If you want to talk to clients, take ownership of cases, go to trial and build real relationships, keep reading.

Why This Role Stands Out

This is not a "stay in your lane and bill quietly" position. We are intentionally developing our next generation of client-facing attorneys and giving them room to grow into trusted advisors.

You'll work directly with experienced litigators while also:

• Speaking with clients early and often
• Taking increasing responsibility over strategy and case management
• Learning how to develop and retain business (with guidance—not pressure)

Practice Focus

• Employment litigation (defense-side experience preferred)
• Exposure to wage & hour, discrimination, harassment, retaliation, and related claims
• Opportunity to assist with other practice areas at the firm including business & real property disputes.

What You'll Get

• Real mentorship and hands-on training
• Direct client interaction (not years down the road—now)
• A path to developing your own book of business over time
• Support, structure, and feedback to help you grow confidently
• A law firm environment that values curiosity, initiative, and communication skills

Who We're Looking For

• 2+ years of employment litigation experience
• Prior law firm experience (this is essential)
• Strong written and verbal communication skills
• Someone who enjoys talking to people—not just writing briefs
• A motivated attorney who sees client development as a skill to learn, not a mystery

The Right Fit

This role is ideal for an attorney who:

• Wants to grow into a long-term career, not just a title
• Is excited by responsibility and learning
• Wants exposure to how law firms actually grow and sustain practices

Start Your Civilian Career with a Global Leader in Dairy Manufacturing

Locations:

• Greeley, CO
• Lemoore, CA
• Fort Morgan, CO
• Allendale, MI

Leprino is offering transitioning service members the opportunity to gain hands-on experience in industrial maintenance through our DoD SkillBridge Maintenance Technician Trainee Program. This 4-6 month program provides immersive, on-the-job training in one of the world's leading dairy foods manufacturing companies, setting you up for a seamless transition into a high-demand civilian career. At Leprino, we pride ourselves on innovation, teamwork, and a strong commitment to excellence. As the largest producer of mozzarella cheese and a global leader in dairy ingredients, we understand the value of highly skilled technical professionals. This program is designed to bridge your military expertise into a thriving career in industrial maintenance.

What You'll Learn & Do

As a Maintenance Technician Trainee, you'll be working alongside seasoned maintenance professionals, gaining real-world experience in maintaining and troubleshooting advanced manufacturing equipment.

Key Responsibilities:

• Perform preventive maintenance on conveyors, motors, pumps, valves, and hydraulic systems.
• Conduct vibration analysis and thermal imaging to predict equipment failures.
• Work with lubrication systems to maintain production equipment.
• Diagnose and repair mechanical, hydraulic, pneumatic, and electrical systems.
• Troubleshoot three-phase motors, motor controls, and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs).
• Work with steam boilers, refrigeration systems, and ammonia-based cooling systems.
• Gain hands-on experience with Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) and Human-Machine Interfaces (HMIs).
• Assist in diagnosing automation system issues using SCADA and industrial networking.
• Perform welding and fabrication for minor equipment repairs and modifications.
• Enter maintenance data and track equipment history in SAP or another CMMS software.
• Support installation, setup, and commissioning of new processing and packaging equipment.
• Work on projects involving robotic automation and advanced processing technology.
• Participate in Lean Manufacturing and Continuous Improvement (CI) initiatives to enhance equipment efficiency.
• Follow OSHA safety standards, Lockout/Tagout (LOTO) procedures, and food safety (GMP, HACCP) protocols.
• Learn arc flash safety and work in high-voltage environments safely and effectively.

This is a structured training program with direct mentorship, on-the-job learning, and exposure to industry-leading maintenance practices that will set you up for long-term career success.

Who We're Looking For

Military service members eligible for the DoD SkillBridge Program (within 180 days of separation).

Experience in the following military maintenance roles:

• Army: 15-series MOS (Aviation Maintenance Technicians).
• Navy: Engineman (EN), Machinist's Mate (MM), Electrician's Mate (EM), Hull Maintenance Technician (HT), Gas Turbine Systems Technician (GS), Machinery Repairman (MR).
• Marines: 60/61/62 (Aircraft Maintenance).
• Air Force: Aircraft Maintenance (2A5X1, 2A3X3), HVAC/R (3E1X1).
• Coast Guard: Machinery Technician (MK), Electronics Technician (ET), Aviation Maintenance Technician (AMT), Electrician's Mate (EM)

Apply Today!

Take the first step toward a rewarding civilian career. If you're a transitioning service member looking for a hands-on, high-paying career in industrial maintenance, we encourage you to apply!

Contact: Iassen Donov –

Visit: to learn more.

Objective:

Heffernan Kettering Rose Insurance is looking for an experienced Commercial Lines Account Executive. This role blends sales responsibilities with those of a typical Executive Account Manager. This is a dynamic role, serving as a team lead supporting their Producer(s) while providing a spectrum of innovative strategies to develop and maintain customers' insurance and risk management needs.

Responsibilities Include:

• Total account responsibility, including marketing and account management for assigned clients.
• Travel for client and carrier meetings, customer events, association events, and conferences. Occasional overnight travel may be necessary.
• Ability to take the lead in managing renewals.
• Cross-sell other lines of coverage when meeting with clients.
• Active participation in client presentations for new and renewal business.
• Development of new business and renewal strategies. This will include preparing specifications and marketing materials, securing underwriting information, analyzing existing coverage, and making recommendations to clients.
• Guide fast-paced new business submissions through underwriting by creating SOV’s, ACORD applications, loss projections, narrative of operations, etc.
• Correspond with producer(s), clients, and underwriters during the submission process..
• Coordinate all aspects of the renewal marketing process with the client and provide program structure, review, and analysis.
• Must be able to handle complex accounts, including account placement, preparing account specifications, price negotiations, and alternative risk services.
• Provide technical competence in areas of coverage and current markets.
• Manage account services, as customary with that of an Executive Account Manager role. Must be capable of managing and balancing many different relationships – including clients, team members and carriers.
• Evaluate insureds' needs, while communicating renewal strategy to the Account Management team.
• Meet regularly with insureds to manage and build rapport throughout the year.
• Conduct various training sessions for clients, including workers' compensation reporting, GL and property reporting awareness, and various strategic trainings throughout the year.
• Attend loss prevention and similar meetings on-site and prepare clients for such meetings.
• Conduct on-site risk audits for prospective clients.
• Attend workers' compensation claims consulting meetings.
• Attend and participate in regular team sales meetings.
• Thorough documentation is required for each account, and E&O procedures must be strictly followed.
• Other duties and special technical projects as assigned.

Requirements:

• Education – High School graduate/GED required.
• Minimum of 5 years of insurance work experience in a related position.
• An active P&C insurance license is required.
• CIC or other advanced designation is preferred.
• Excellent communication and collaboration skills required.
• Proven analytical, marketing, and organizational skills.
• Proficient in MS Office (Excel, PowerPoint, Word, etc.)
• Must be organized and able to manage time effectively.
• Must embody the Heffernan Habits as illustrated herein.

Compensation:

The base salary range for this position is $125,000.00 to $150,000.00. The offer will depend on the geographic region, job-related knowledge, skills, and experience, among other factors. This role will be eligible to participate in a discretionary annual incentive program.

Heffernan Habits (Expectations):

These are practices that represent our unique culture.

• Answer The Phone (And Email): Communication is the foundation of success in life, work, and relationships. It begins with being present and responsive to both clients and colleagues. Listen to what is said and notice what goes unsaid.
• Have Fun: Fun is something we don’t shy away from, and participation brings us together on many different levels. Take the time to know your colleagues and let barriers fall away. If we are happy and enjoy time together, we will do a better job for our clients and for one another!
• Be Respectful: Lend a hand, be kind, and smooth the path. Respect is the cornerstone of developing and maintaining strong relationships. Lead with humility, take ownership of your actions, and ease the way for others. We are in this together as a team, as a family, and as trusted advisors to many.
• Do Good: This is our core. We strive to do good for our clients, our community, and our planet.
• Celebrate & Value Our Differences:“Because You’re Different”. It is our differences, when valued and amplified, that allow us to innovate, to learn, to connect, and to stand apart from the rest.

Working Conditions:

• Work environment is indoors, sitting at a desk or standing for extended periods of time.
• Daily use of computers, keyboard, mouse, headset, printers, and other commonly used office equipment.
• This position may require flexibility to work hours outside of a regular schedule.
• Ability to travel as necessary.

Help us change lives

At Exact Sciences, we're helping change how the world prevents, detects and guides treatment for cancer. We give patients and clinicians the clarity needed to make confident decisions when they matter most. Join our team to find a purpose-driven career, an inclusive culture, and robust benefits to support your life while you're working to help others.

Position Overview

The Lead AI Safety and Enablement Engineer ensures the safe, reliable and scalable use of AI and machine learning across Exact Sciences. This role focuses on developing and implementing systems, tools, and frameworks that embed responsible AI principles into the organization's technology ecosystem. The position combines software engineering expertise with a strong understanding of AI risk management, compliance, and observability.

This role is based in one of our office location. Relocation assistance provided to those not local to the area and willing to relocate.

Essential Duties

Include, but are not limited to, the following:

• Support implementation of enterprise standards for AI safety, transparency, and reliability.
• Develop and maintain shared AI safety tools such as model catalogs, metadata registries, and monitoring systems for bias, drift, and performance.
• Build APIs, templates, and SDKs that integrate governance and validation into AI/ML development pipelines.
• Contribute to the design of observability and telemetry solutions for continuous monitoring of model and data quality.
• Collaborate with Legal, Privacy, Compliance, and InfoSec teams to translate AI policies into automated controls and technical safeguards.
• Work with ML and GenAI teams to embed validation and safety checkpoints in AI workflows.
• Participate in cross-functional reviews and discussions supporting AI governance and responsible AI practices.
• Promote awareness and adoption of responsible AI principles through tools, documentation, and knowledge sharing.
• Support and comply with the company's Quality Management System policies and procedures.
• Uphold company mission and values through accountability, innovation, integrity, quality, and teamwork.
• Maintain regular and reliable attendance.
• Ability to act with an inclusion mindset and model these behaviors for the organization.

Minimum Qualifications

• Bachelor's degree in Computer Science, Software Engineering, Artificial Intelligence, or a related field.
• 8 years of experience in software, ML systems, or platform engineering.
• Practical experience with AI lifecycle tools (e.g., MLflow, Arize, WhyLabs, Label Studio).
• Proficiency in Python, CI/CD processes, and cloud platforms (AWS, Azure, or GCP).
• Experience developing scalable and compliant ML systems and tools.
• Applicants must be currently authorized to work in country where work will be performed on a full or part-time basis. We are unable to sponsor or take over sponsorship of employment visas at this time.

Preferred Qualifications

• Master's degree in Computer Science, Data Engineering, or AI.
• Experience implementing AI assurance, observability, or risk management frameworks.
• Knowledge of GenAI, LLM evaluation, and prompt safety practices.
• Familiarity with FDA, HIPAA, or GxP compliance standards.

Salary Range:

$184,000.00- $276,000.00

Exact Sciences is proud to offer an employee experience that includes paid time off (including days for vacation, holidays, volunteering, and personal time), paid leave for parents and caregivers, a retirement savings plan, wellness support, and health benefits including medical, prescription drug, dental, and vision coverage. Learn more about our benefits.

Our success relies on the experiences and perspectives of a diverse team, and Exact Sciences fosters a culture where all employees can develop personally and professionally with a sense of respect and belonging. If you require an accommodation, please contact us here.

Not ready to apply? Join our Talent Community to stay updated on the latest news and opportunities at Exact Sciences.

We are an equal employment opportunity employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to disability, protected veteran status, and any other status protected by applicable local, state, or federal law.

To view the Right to Work, E-Verify Employer, and Pay Transparency notices and Federal, Federal Contractor, and State employment law posters, visit our compliance hub. The documents summarize important details of the law and provide key points that you have a right to know.